The Society has two awards. The Pine and Iron Award is for people who have done something of note to preserve local history. The Winn Rothman History Award is for literary works regarding history. The awards are considered annually and awarded when deserving.
1980: None
1981: None
1982: Clifford Swanson, Alice Loberg (posthumously)
1983: None
1984: Guy Gibson, Raymond Specht
1985: Maurice Perrett
1986: John Joanis, Wendell Nelson, Justin Isherwood
1987: Jay Price, Patricia Malick
1988: William McKee
1989: John Seramur, Robert Hetchler
1990: K.B. Willett, John Anderson
1991: Tom Brown
1992: Loras Smithback
1993: Worzella Publishing, Phil Kallas
1994: Roy Menzel, William Paul
1995: Don Kottke
1996: Cheryl Jean, Dave Cash
1997: Chuck Nason, Donna Sowka
1998: Polish Heritage Awareness Society, Janet Jurgella
1999: Terry Anderson, Ed Marcks
2000: Lutheran Brotherhood, Ron Coker
2001: Carla Boettcher
2002: None
2003: None
2004: None
2005: None
2006: None
2007: Fred Haase
2008: None
2009: None
2010: Larry Misiewicz
2011: Judy Lyons
2012: None
2013: None
2014: None
2015: None
2016: None
2017: Kirby Heck
2018: Shirley Multhauf
2019: None
2020: John Harry
2021:
1977: Ellen Johnson and John Stastny
1978: Donald Isherwood
1979: Tom Marchel
1980: Wendell Nelson
1981: Malcolm Rosholt
1982: David Tesch
1983: Marjorie Bronsted & Ethelyn Aanrud
1984: Brian Hackett
1985: Wayne Guyant & Dennis Kolinski
1986: Peggy Murray
1987: Wayne Guyant & Janice Hughes
1988: Eugene Isherwood
1989: Stevens Point Historic Design & Review Commission
1990: Malcolm Rosholt, Craig Anderson, Connie Haack-Hurlbut
1991: None
1992: None
1993: Adeline Sopa & Milicent Hild
1994: Agnes Golla
1995: None
1996: Russell Haines & Justus Paul
2002: None
2003: None
2004: John Kiedrowski, Mr. & Mrs Leary
2005: None
2006: None
2007: None
2008: None
2009: None
2010: Mark Seiler
2011: None
2012: None
2013: None
2014: None
2015: None
2016: None
2017: None
2018: Diane Lang & Brad Casselberry, John Harry
2019: Patti Drier
2020: None
2021: